I do not understand what the problem is with my Community Wiki question: What's your favorite alternative tuning and why? [closed].
We expect answers to be supported by facts, references, or specific expertise, but this question will likely solicit debate, arguments, polling, or extended discussion.
Example songs are facts. Why it's your favorite is specific expertise. The word OR means only one of these is needed.
Debate?!! Is somebody gonna disagree about What's your favorite?
Arguments?!! While I agree that debate is bad, arguments are good. Why solicits (good) arguments.
Polling? Well, yeah. That's the territory. Same with extended discussion.
Alternate Tunings is precisely the sort of topic that needs this kind of treatment. Sure you can find lists of tunings and songs out there. But when you're just beginning to explore these things, a little guidance or endorsement is nice.